5 /5 Marlon: Five stars without hesitation. This is easily one of the top five lobster rolls I’ve ever had, and I travel all over the country for work, so that list isn’t exactly short. DJ’s packs theirs with fresh, sweet lobster in a way that makes you feel like they’re trying to spoil you. The roll is perfectly toasted, the fries come out crispy enough to actually crunch, and the whole plate just hits.
The courtyard vibe seals the deal. It’s the kind of spot where you sit down for lunch and suddenly consider canceling the rest of your afternoon. Laid-back, welcoming, and the perfect place to demolish a lobster roll that won first place for a reason.
If you’re anywhere near St. Augustine, this is a must-stop.