Alfanos Pizzeria - (Near Monmouth, IL)

5 /5 Gregory: Enjoyed some pizza today at Alfanos in Monmouth. Their restaurant has two rooms for seating. Lots to choose from. Pizza was great. Good amount of cheese, sauce is sweet and tangy, and dough was of good consistency. Carry out and delivery available. Good family restaurant for a small town. Service was good and polite. Well priced. Worth a visit!

5 /5 kevin dillard: Had supper there on this past Friday night. Superb service and great pizza. Highly recommend. Had the stuffed taco pizza and there was no way it could have been better and the service was prompt,polite and the best I could have asked for. I wish I could give them more than five stars honestly

5 /5 Martin Rodrick: After all these years, it is still authentic Alfanos Pizza! The same ingredients from the same suppliers after 50 years!!! Thanks Alberto! Back in the area for a visit during the holidays and was hoping to stop in. I am thrilled to know you are enjoying your holiday vacation and not overworking yourself! Would be good to see you again though, Alberto! Keep thinking about my last visit, it was awesome!

1 /5 April McInnis: Disappointed to say the least. We ordered what was on the menu as a “Chicago style pizza”. When it arrived it was nothing more than a regular pizza. When I asked the server about it she replied that they only have “pan” pizza. I wouldn’t consider it that either. She almost seemed like “Oh, well … too bad” and then asked if we wanted a box for the rest of it. No offer to make anything right. I thought it was very unprofessional. When I mentioned the incident to the owner she wasn’t any more helpful. She started off by reading that portion of the menu to me and when I stopped her by telling her “I can read” she began making excuses for the server -“We’ll, she’s a high schooler and that’s what you can expect.” Excuse me?! What I can expect is for the owner to care enough about the customers who are keeping their business afloat to take it a little more seriously. She did offer to remake something or give us a credit since my husband had already paid the bill but at that point I was just ready to be done with the place. We won’t be returning or recommending Alfano’s to anyone but will share our experience if anyone asks about the place.

5 /5 Zamiel C. Peterson: I always order a stuffed specialty breadstick from here and its always good and delivered in about 35 to 40 min regardless of how busy they get. Always crispy and deliciously melty cheese with flavorful ingredients and a golden brown toasting and I had taken their service for granted that is till I ordered from galesburgs alfanos. Oh boy, dont do that. This alfanos is awesome and if it were so easy they should just take over the other location. It makes alfanos look abysmal to anyone living in galesburg. And if you read this all, yes this is pretty much just a second bad review of the galesburg alfanos. It was so bad I had to tell other alfanos they need to fix their sibling or start an intervention for em.