2 /5 Ashley: Coney Island was opened in 1921 and is Galesburg’s oldest restaurant.
We ordered the Coney Dog, a Kraut Dog and the BLT Dog. The prices sound reasonable, $3.50, but the hotdogs were lackluster. You could honestly find more flavor in a gas station hotdog than here, which was HUGELY disappointing. The hotdogs are extremely similar to a Bar S brand hotdog, which has to be one of the cheapest hotdogs you can buy. You would think that you would want a quality hotdog when that is your theme.
Very disappointed and wouldn’t return.
For more food reviews, follow us on Facebook, Instagram and TikTok @gbdiningdykes