1 /5 SQH: Ive never run so fast to write a review. So, this is my second time visiting this place. The first time I ordered a general meat platter that had a mix of ribs, pulled pork, brisket, etc. The meat was a little dry, but better than most Binghamton area BBQ weve had. But, the second time, I ordered the fried catfish meal plate. My full order was fried catfish, salt potatoes, and macaroni salad with cornbread.
So, before I even opened the bag, I could smell the fishy odor coming from the catfish which immediately turned me off to the food, but when I opened the container, I was baffled? confused? at what I saw. The catfish resembled a chicken cutlet? Veal? The pieces were small and red. In short, they looked nothing like the pictures provided on the restaurant website but more so, they looked nothing like a piece of catfish Ive ever eaten. Fried catfish is a very straightforward meal to make, my meal resembled nothing Ive ever seen. To be honest, the fish tasted and resembled bad tilapia, but I cant confirm so lets just assume it was catfish.
I took a bite and winced, at how nasty the fish was. It is certainly not of good quality, and also likely is a bit spoiled. It was lightly fried? Burnt? I dont know what I ate, but I had a visceral reaction to the taste and texture, so I said, okay, let me try the sides. I took a bite of the salt potatoes and nearly chipped a tooth. The potatoes were not cooked through so they were still raw/hard, there goes that side!
Next was the mac salad. It was also a bit dry. Not terrible, but certainly not creamy and good.
The cornbread. A classic...was sadly ruined by the fishy order that took over the entire container the takeout was in.
Lastly, aside from this specific order, I just wanted to point out how exclusive this restaurant is. Over the past year Ive tried to get food several times and have only been successful twice because every other time theyre closed with little to no notice.
That shouldve been a sign.
Advice to MGMT/Chefs: Consistency breeds quality. Currently there is none in the hours, food, or service.
Ive also added photos of what the fried catfish is advertised as on their site versus what I got.