Cooleys Stone House Tavern - (Near Cooperstown, NY)

4 /5 Joshua Knoll: When you first approach from the outside this place seems a bit like it was closed as you approach. Once inside it’s not a huge place but has that very old bar feeling to it. Our table was very wobbly so we grabbed bar seats. Drinks were made and as we were sitting there we noticed a ton of fruit flys which isn’t a good thing. But the food we ordered looked good. I ordered my burger well done and got cowboy fritters. The fritters were outstanding! The French fries I got with my burger were excellent as well. The burger was good up until I noticed that it wasn’t fully cooked I noticed a little pink inside. Which is fine for some. But a huge turn off on the food for me. Overall I’d give it a 4/5 stars the atmosphere was ok. For how old the place is I get the historical aspect of it.

5 /5 Rob Gilleece: Theres a sign outside that said the building was from the 1800s and I believe it! Theres plenty of historical ambience to this place and we enjoyed it. The table we chose was in a corner and slightly tilted but it was still comfortable and cozy. The food was certainly pub grub but of very high quality. The house sauce (for the wings) is kind of a chipotle BBQ sauce and I recommend it. The onion rings, sweet potato fries, and pretzel were all excellent. Two of us had a burger and we both loved them. The service was also perfect; Erin was a true professional and treated us well. The fact that I had an IPA from the local brewery (Ommegang) made the meal even better! We were in town for the Hall of Fame and am so glad we stopped in at Cooleys!

4 /5 PhilYouIn: Just around the corner from the Baseball Hall Of Fame. Not too amenable for large parties. Decent beer selection, and the four apps we shared were pretty good. The server we asked for a table told us there was no room for us, so we pulled six bar chairs around a high table and were eventually served. Not bad.

5 /5 Casey Woodley: Had the French Dip and a Chicken Caesar Salad. It was absolutely delicious! Every local football game on for Sunday at 1:00. Service was super fast and wonderfully friendly. Will absolutely be back.

3 /5 Brad Moyer: Was up to visit the baseball HOF and stopped to check out this place for lunch. It was a nice old school place inside and out. The waitress was very helpful and good. Got a burger and the cowboy fritters and both tasted very good. The only downside I had was it seemed like the place was very dirty. I was sitting at the bar and there was fruit flies everywhere and just landing/sitting on the cups and in your way while eating your food. Was nice to try it but won’t be back.