Mattys Pizza - (Near Batavia, NY)

5 /5 Shannon: Coming back to Batavia we ended up getting Mattys because Mattys used to be my mothers favorite pizza before we moved out of state. 1st... the guy at the counter was VERY friendly and we talked about the pizza shops back in the day and got some Mattys history. 2nd, the place it is located ( Eli Fish Brewing Co ) is soooo spacious with friendly workers. 3rd...the pizza...oh my gosh! So yummy! Crust not too thick but not thin either. Cooked perfectly. We got a large cheese, pepperoni and mushroom. Perfect amount of cheese, large pepperoni and those thick mushrooms. Toppings were plenty. We ordered at the pizza counter within Elis.and it didnt take very long at all. Totally recommend it!

3 /5 Pete: This is My first time ever ordering and trying Mattys Pizza. I moved near the area about a year ago and I usually order pizza from 151 Pizza which is pretty good but I wanted to try something different so I ordered a large one topping cup and char pepperoni from Mattys. Only took 15 minutes to make which is great but for some reason the cheese just had a weird taste/texture. The cheese tasted like it was very very cheap cheese. The pepperoni was good The pizza itself with the sauce was good but that cheese, I just can get past it... There was something about it, It tastes like skim milk Aldis shredded cheese. Would I go back to try it again? probably not, The pizza itself 1-10 Id give it a 5.9.

4 /5 Sean Maloney: Pizza is good, definitely above average! Medium wings were on the salty side (go figure since they want you to drink at Eli Fish) but overall not bad.

1 /5 Joseph Harper: I ordered a 10” Supreme pizza through DoorDash but was delivered a Pepperoni its all on this restaurant because of my bad experience first time ordering from here is this what they do to Doordash customers or is it just me

3 /5 Katie Keedy: Pretty gross that someone thought this was acceptable. Not one pepperoni was edible; all burnt to heck.