Tinellis - (Near Cincinnatus, NY)

Morgan Boyce The inside is very cute and there is a HUGE selection of flavors. The lady running the show is very friendly and does a great job. Best of all, the shake I got, Very Berry, tasted amazing. Highly recommend to anyone who’s a fan of shakes!! And they have coffees and energy drinks too! I’m definitely going to be a weekly customer

Ash Willows Amazing BBQ place! The banana split was so good. Definitely healed part of my soul. The BBQ was good, the sides were also amazing. We got baked beans, mac, potato and broccoli salads. Absolutely recommend!

Chandler H Really enjoyed our meal here. The food was incredible, the wine pairings were delicious and it was a nice, cozy/cute atmosphere. Sitting at a communal table was awesome - very much felt like a fancy dinner at a friend’s place where you are meeting new people. Well… If your friend can cook damn good food and serves awesome wine. Enjoyed it and would recommend to everyone who visits the finger lakes or for a special occasion.

Rachael Van Tassel The person taking my order was helpful in identifying gluten free options, and then helpful choosing from all of them. I ordered the dill pickle grilled cheese on gf bread, though it was a hard choice between that and gf pancakes. They can also make the grilled cheese vegan. Sandwich was delicious and I finished it off with a lovely slice of gf rhubarb pie! The wait was a little long, but I didn’t mind browsing around Vineyard View winery until my buzzer went off. Nice picnic tables to sit on outside overlooking the lake.

Thomas Hinrichs This is by far the best Greek food around. We live in Port Jefferson and use to go to Hampton Bays for Hampton Gyro. We are so happy they opened one in Riverhead. Best Food, Best Service, Beautiful Restaurant.

Rick Deguido Pizza is good ! Better if you ask to keep it in the oven 5 extra minutes.. could use less flop but overall not bad