ny Date: 05-21-2026

List 2 Budget-Friendly Restaurants Near You in Mayville, New York (Part 2)

Find the List 2 budget-friendly restaurants near you in Mayville, New York, ideal for cheap, tasty, and satisfying meals.

restaurantsAddressPrice_level
1Pueblo Real43 S Erie St, Mayville, NY 14757Undetermined
2The Best of Buffalo by Byron - Food TruckVaries--->https://easyeats.xyz/menu/f/ind/fid, 474 Water St, Mayville, NY 14757Undetermined

1.Pueblo Real

Address: 43 S Erie St, Mayville, NY 14757

(130) user ratings total:

Matt Jones Relatively new restaurant in Mayville. Went on a whim with the wife and we loved it! It was packed for a Thursday night, but the staff had us at a table immediately. With 5 minutes, we had drinks ordered and some chips with salsa. The salsa was quite nice, too. I got a burrito diabla and my wife got a fajita bowl. I doubt we waited more than 10 minutes before the food was served. Both of us really liked our meals and packed some away for lunch the next day. Something important to know is that they are still waiting for their liquor license, so no cocktails or beer...yet. Also, parking is available. If they are busy, you may have to walk a few minutes to get to the restaurant. Finally, the service was awesome. We were helped by no less than 5 staff, which made the whole experience that much better. All in all, definitely come give Pueblo Real a try!
5 /5
=

2.The Best of Buffalo by Byron - Food Truck

Address: Varies--->https://easyeats.xyz/menu/f/ind/fid, 474 Water St, Mayville, NY 14757

(11) user ratings total:

Ross Barr We had chicken wings & pizza logs, my husband loved the wings… he got a spicy bourbon and said it was outstanding. Pizza logs were good. Fast service! A good variety of food. We had their food at Busti Apple Festival! I hope they return each year
5 /5
=