2 /5 E: âïžâïž | Great Service, Beautiful AtmosphereâBut Disappointing Food & Value
Last night was our first visit to The Presidentâs Pub , and while we had high hopes, the experience didnât live up to expectationsâaside from the amazing service we received from our waitress, Casey. She was attentive, kind, and really made us feel welcomed. Honestly, she was the best part of the evening.
We started with the stuffed crab mushrooms appetizer, which was absolutely deliciousâflavorful and cooked perfectly. Things seemed promising at that point.
For our main courses, we ordered the Scottish salmon and a the delmonico steak. The salmon started off okay for the first few bites, but as I got to the center, it was rawâdefinitely not the medium cook I asked for. The rice and vegetables on the side, however, were solid. The steak was requested medium rare, but it came out fully cooked with no pink at all. The mashed potatoes were overwhelmed with thyme, which unfortunately overpowered the dish.
We appreciated that the kitchen timed the courses well, and we werenât overwhelmed with everything at once.
As for drinks, we ordered an Aloha Breeze and a plain margarita. Both were a letdownâneither drink tasted balanced or enjoyable.
We dined outside, which was visually stunning. The waterfall, sunflowers, and tomato plants made for a beautiful setting. That said, it was bug city out there. Some citronella candles or bug control would go a long way. The outdoor seating could also use an upgradeâmore comfortable chairs would make a big difference.
The final disappointment was the bill. With two drinks, one appetizer, and two entrees, we were shocked that the total came to $103.00. If the food and drinks had been exceptional, it wouldâve been easier to justify. But for the quality we received, it felt overpriced.
The name âPresidentâs Pubâ gave us high expectations, but while Casey made us feel like VIPs, the food and drinks did not. We may or may not return again, but weâre grateful for the service and the atmosphere.
