Christian Moreno I had an absolutely amazing experience at Old Hickory Steakhouse. Since our party was larger than four, I couldn’t book through the OpenTable website, so I called directly to make a reservation for six—and the process was smooth and welcoming from the start.
We were celebrating my dad’s birthday, and the attention to detail from the moment we arrived was outstanding. The staff surprised him with a handwritten birthday card, which was such a thoughtful and personal touch—it immediately set the tone for the evening and made the occasion feel extra special.
We started with a round of fresh oysters, which were delicious—perfectly chilled, flavorful, and beautifully presented. Most of us ordered the porterhouse steak, and it was absolutely incredible—cooked to perfection, tender, and full of rich, bold flavor.
The drinks were fantastic as well. There was a moment when my sister didn’t like her cocktail, and the staff was more than happy to replace it with something she’d enjoy—no hesitation, just great hospitality.
Later in the evening, after a few drinks and lots of laughter, I didn’t realize I had left behind the card I used to pay. To my surprise, the staff called me and left a voicemail to let me know and hold it for me. That level of honesty and care says so much about the kind of team they have—professional, attentive, and genuinely customer-focused.
From start to finish, everything about our night was memorable: the service, the food, the drinks, and the little moments that made it all feel personal. I’ll always carry a great memory of this night and I’ve already recommended Old Hickory to several friends. Whether you’re celebrating something special or just want a top-tier dinner experience, this place is a must.
