Cass Cay Restaurant & Bar - (Near Punta Gorda, FL)

5 /5 W. V. F.: Located at Burnt Store Marina (gated), the place isn’t easy to reach but well worth the drive. For such a setting, the prices ( even post happy hour) are decent and their food is above average. Great steak and smash burgers. Bands on the weekends. As others have stated, the service is good but not exactly fast. We’d have probably gotten a couple of more drinks had they arrived faster.

3 /5 Kelly Peluso: Recent visit update. The service is terrible. We were there for about 4 hours for a live music event. Our server took our order for my daughters meal, the food took longer than what she told us, and she never came back to check on us. I did tell her when placing the initial order that I was going to want to order something for myself. She was helping every other table around us. Ended up asking another server for a couple of waters since our drinks were empty. You could see that he wasnt happy with hearing that we werent being helped. I ended up not eating. Had to stop somewhere else after leaving. Shameful. Nice view. Food is just okay. Be prepared to be bitten by noseeums once the sun goes down. Bring bug spray.

5 /5 Doug Kyle: Went for brunch buffet. Overall good experience. Learned once we got there the blood Mary special no longer existed. So $2.00 turned into 9 dollars... that was disappointing. Eggs left alot to be desired on the buffet but everything else was good. Overall very decent meal for 13 dollars.. Service was good. Nice restaurant with nice views.

1 /5 BK Hill: READ BEFORE YOU EVER THINK OF COMING HERE!!! If you see “Ian”- short guy with tattoos on his one arm- leave. He will attack you for any complaints. He also made all 3 of my children cry by attacking my mother, father and I. Awful excuse for a “manager”. Had an awful experience tonight 12/28. The food took about 2 hours, and when we had asked for a manager to talk about it, a guy named Ian (short guy with a sleeve tattoo) came out and insulted my mother and father for complaining about the food before coming after me. My mother had told him it took a while, to which he said “did you have a reservation? Who goes out with 7 people without a reservation. We’re short staffed, nothing we can do”. My dad said “I ran a business for 40+ years, that’s no way to talk to a customer” to which he replied “it’s 2025”. I said “listen, we’re not trying to argue bro” and he snapped back saying, ‘I’m not your bro’. I replied, “fine, you’re not my bro, but we’re not trying to argue, we’ve just been waiting for 2 hours so we’re a bit upset” and he said I was a liar and walked away, flipping me off and cussing at me when he got to the kitchen doors. SIDE NOTE: Ian- you’re a scared punk for doing that. After a few more nasty remarks from behind closed doors, we decided to leave. The waitress apologized what felt like 10 times, saying she was mortified that he acted that way. I told her it wasn’t her fault, but coming after my family and myself, in front of my 10, 8, 7, and newborn children, the managers actions were completely uncalled for. This restaurant must be run by Ian’s parents or something, because this guy shouldn’t have a job. We received no apology and instead were belittled for coming in on a Sunday evening- when they weren’t busy- to have dinner. I’ve never been treated so badly in my entire life. 0/10. Awful food. Awful treatment from the manager. To our waitress (blonde girl)- you were amazing. I’m sorry you have to work under someone like that!

5 /5 John Taylor: Very busy! Staff can get overwhelmed so you need to be patient. They do a great job adapting to the size of the crowd. Did is cooked the way you want, it comes out hot. The prices are very fair, they have great specials and the outside deck had some of the nicest bands in the area there! They are really good musicians and fun. You want a nice meal with friends priced very reasonable? This is the Friday and Saturday evening you need to experience. Been there 4 times this month. Lunch with my daughter, again priced very reasonable. Not extremely busy, service was great. Very attentive servers and the order comes as you ordered. They take reservations and I highly recommend doing that for the evening dinners on the weekend.