5 /5 Scott Rudisel: Located on North Hutchinson Island Sharkeys is one of the few restaurants in the area. Luckily, the food and atmosphere are worth the stop. Typically we go there for a sandwich, which are always great. However, recently, we decided to try the pizza. We hadn’t had one in a few years from there. The pizzas have greatly improved and now Sharkey’s is in our top five of local pizzas.