Top 15 Affordable Restaurants in New Castle, PA

Howard Pierce Entered and had a slight wait with no one in line. Restaurant looks clean. Given a booth with a slight wait for a drink. Waitress friendly enough and brought extra napkins, which is a plus. Unsweetened tea not bad with lemon. Ordered a 9.99 meal of chopped steak over mashed potatoes with sauteed onions and mushrooms. No gravy. Probably would have tasted better with the gravy, but trying gluten free. They did serve a roll with cinnamon butter. Decent meal. Decided on cheese cake with blueberries. Plenty of berries. I was pleased here. Clean bathroom.

travel2418 We found this restaurant by going to the 4 Seasons Flea market on Sundays! They have a food truck there you can order from. I am glad the food at the truck and the restaurant taste the same! This establishment is beautiful! They have a small bar, decorations and a relaxing atmosphere. We will be dining in, since we ordered online this time. Reccomend 100%. Food is always consistently delicious and clean!

Logan Edmiston A classic Italian restaurant with a strong sports theme. Its very clean, has abundant seating, and has very friendly and efficient wait staff. This is rich food, not necessarily good if you are on a strict diet. Has some unique options for breakfast. Very family oriented. Mostly older clientele with families.

Jake Sager These guys get a five star review for me because they take precautions. I ordered a pizza and then some pepperoni rolls with sauce. They wrapped their sauce in plastic wrap. On the way home, the whole bag fell onto the floor of my brand new truck. I initially was very upset until I walked around and saw that the cups of sauce were wrapped in plastic wrap and completely safe. Thank you for saving my vehicle

Matt McConahy Had a party for 20 in a private room last night for my mom’s 90th birthday. Easy to make the arrangements being from out of town. The food and hospitality was top shelf. The steak and gnocchi were the top highlights but everything was delicious and reasonably priced. Everyone in our party were complimentary. They let us in early to decorate for the party. Wait staff was professional and responsive. Thanks to everyone there for making this event a highlight for our mom.

Aunt Nessie $25 for 4 people, large chili/cheese fries, 5 hotdogs, roast beef melt (on Texas toast), and 4 waters. I dont think the price was bad. It’s 5 hotdogs for $7.50. They served us with a smile when the cashier took our order and when another woman gave us our tray, so then I watched the customers after us (even 10 -20 mins later) and each worker was serving them with a smile. So great service, they all seemed hard at work. Food tasted great, just the way it should be I like that they warm the buns for the hotdogs, food tasted perfect. I think they’re the only ones that have those lemon packets to put in water which I love! Restaurant was clean. The fries were medium thick size and tasted fresh! They weren’t too thin, just perfect. Restrooms weee clean also. I loved the melted roast beef on Texas toast, amazing. Defiantly will return.

Sherri Mazzanti Such a great little spot. Everything I’ve tried there has been delicious. My favorite is the ‘Michael’s Signature’ acai cup. The fruit is always on point and super fresh. Gianna has been there every time I’ve popped in, and she is just a great presence and personality to have greeting and waiting on customers. It’s a really nice atmosphere…from the people working there, to the cleanliness, quality of your food/shake, and the nice seating area they have set up. Definitely stop in and check them out if you haven’t already!

Herb Hatfield This is a awesome place church service is held every Sunday is held at 10:30 a.m

Mallory Dugan My family loves to come here. Ive been a patron since they came into the old Wendys further down the road, and continued to come as I started and grew a family. Antonio is the best and we will be forever customers at this family restaurant.

Brady Lego Great coffee!! I recommend getting their muffins they are baked fresh!! Their “the uge” latte is amazing!! Perfectly sweet coffee a great environment and vibe to the store!! I seriously recommend popping in for a bite to eat for breakfast, lunch, or dessert!

Scarnati Bernadette (Bern!e) I had a most enjoyable "take-out" dinner experience! Betsys genial demeanor was welcoming and familiar, my incredibly delicious sirloin was perfectly prepared and truly enjoyed. I cant say enough about the mouthwatering, delicious food. Starwood is an absolute must visit establishment. Im certainly going to become a regular patron. Thank you Bernadette

Judy Champion They are only open Sundays. Must maje a Reservation. Best Italian Dinner We had with our Family in years! Thanks to their friendly, kind servers, hostess, and all the wonderful cooks! Thank You All or a wonderful memory!

Lisa Barr Wonderful place! Food was amazing! Very tasty sauces, breads, foods. You can tell they are made in house. Great waitresses and atmosphere. Spacious and many TV’s to watch sports.

Marissa Cotelesse My absolute favorite place to eat in Shenango!!! Age and her staff are always offering the best customer service to make my hot dog and milkshakes perfect!!! If you haven’t been to coney in Shenango yet you’re missing out!!!!

Valencia Castillo Cedars is a local joint that gives hefty portions, the staff are friendly and quick. The Syrian bread has a nice crust, and soft pillowy center. I highly recommend the Pittsburgh sandwich, we also were here for wings night, the wings were fantastic.They give a healthy serving of fresh cut fries, with in house made ranch dressing. If you are coming in to New Castle, you must stop in and try a place that locals love, and have enjoyed for over 65 years.