5 /5 sutherlandk19: Papa Vitos is my favorite pizza place in town. The entrance to the restaurant sets the mood with a historic home feel, low-lighting, and aged photos of the original building. I came here most recently on Valentines Day to pick up a to-go order and the place was packed, unsurprisingly. The KSHE radio station ranked Papa Vitos to have the best pizza in the St. Louis area. I probably wouldnt go so far as to say that, but it is quite tasty.
For three people, we ordered two 8-inch personal pizzas, a French-dip sandwich (my husbands all-time-favorite sandwich, which is made perfectly here), and their house salad. All three of us got a second meal from our leftovers. They offer signature pizzas, but also allow you to build your own.
As it was Valentines Day, my food was ready 10 minutes after the scheduled time and the bag was missing a requested extra sauce item. All in all, our experience was nearly top notch and Im looking forward to my next visit.