5 /5 Laina Karosic: This is now Moonfish Brewery, and it still has the familiar feel of the old Riverhead Brew House, just under new ownership. The overall setup and atmosphere are pretty much the same, which works because the space is genuinely large, open, and easy for groups. It’s the kind of place where you can show up with a handful of friends or a big crowd and still find plenty of seating without much hassle.
The menu hasn’t changed much either. Portions are generous, and there’s enough variety for most people to find something they’re comfortable ordering. Typical bar food options - nachos, burgers, etc. I’d recommend the pickle chips as an appetizer - they were the clear favorite at our table. We all ordered flights and liked the IPAs and the sour; both were solid picks and made it easy to try a little bit of everything without committing to a full pour.
Service was friendly and laid-back, which fit the overall vibe of the place. The staff was attentive and told us about the new ownership. They were out of a few beers we chose for our flights, but we were able to all get something we liked. Staff was also very accommodating when we had a special request with one of our orders. I’d return, especially once the weather warms up. The outdoor patio across from the river is a great spot to spend time, and it adds a nice reason to come back in the summer.
