ny Date: 05-21-2026

Top 15 Affordable Restaurants in Waterloo, NY

Check out the top 15 affordable restaurants in [Waterloo, NY] with popular menu items, price ranges, and honest reviews.

Affordable RestaurantsAddressPrice_level
1Subway1262 NY-414, Waterloo, NY 13165Undetermined
2Connies Diner205 E Main St, Waterloo, NY 13165Inexpensive
3New First Dragon5 E Main St, Waterloo, NY 13165Inexpensive
4Pats Pizzeria1963 Kingdom Plaza, Waterloo, NY 13165Inexpensive
513 Indian Taste & Salad655 NY-318, Waterloo, NY 13165Moderate
6Monterrey Mexican Grill1303 NY-414, Waterloo, NY 13165Moderate
7Woodys Bar and Grille2468 NY-414, Waterloo, NY 13165Undetermined
8The Green Apple19 W Main St, Waterloo, NY 13165Moderate
9Portico at del Lago Resort and Casino1133 NY-414, Waterloo, NY 13165Undetermined
10McDonalds2500 Mound Road, Waterloo, NY 13165Inexpensive
11Sociale Café at del Lago Resort & Casino1133 NY-414, Waterloo, NY 13165Undetermined
12Lizard’s Tailgator Lounge40 Church St, Waterloo, NY 13165Inexpensive
13Ciccinos Pizzeria & Restaurant22 E Main St, Waterloo, NY 13165Moderate
14Steak and PotatoFinger lake Premium Outlets (Food Court, 655 NY-318 #31D, Waterloo, NY 13165Inexpensive
15Bourbon & Brew1133 NY-414, Waterloo, NY 13165Undetermined

1.Subway

Address: 1262 NY-414, Waterloo, NY 13165

(28) user ratings total:

Chadwick Zaleski Natalie did an amazing job. Took time to make the sub and put a lot of care into it
5 /5
=

2.Connies Diner

Address: 205 E Main St, Waterloo, NY 13165

images Connies Diner

(2759) user ratings total:

Holly Mosher Stopped on a whim, hungry. Very busy on a Friday afternoon about 5pm but we found a seat at the counter. Immediately waited on & food came quickly. Hot, fresh, abundant & a excellent fish fry supper at a great price. Cool place, lots to look at, quite popular. Cash only with atm in entry way. No alcohol, ice cream fountain available.
5 /5
=

3.New First Dragon

Address: 5 E Main St, Waterloo, NY 13165

(257) user ratings total:

becki jade Hands down some of the best food I have had !!!! The egg rolls were delish!!! They have this sauce that was served along with the meal (a little salty) that was so flavorful!!! They even serve wonton strips while you wait!!!! Their fried dumplings! Were so good!!!
5 /5
=

4.Pats Pizzeria

Address: 1963 Kingdom Plaza, Waterloo, NY 13165

(238) user ratings total:

Elliott Hoth Ive ordered from Pats Pizzeria in Waterloo several times, and its hands down the best pizza in the Finger Lakes! The crust is perfectly crispy, the toppings are fresh, and the cheese is always melted to perfection. The staff is friendly and the service is quick, making it my go-to spot for a delicious meal. Whether youre a local or just passing through, dont miss out on this gem. Highly recommend!
5 /5
=

5.13 Indian Taste & Salad

Address: 655 NY-318, Waterloo, NY 13165

(225) user ratings total:

Angela Cavanagh Absolutely delicious food! We all shared a few different dishes to get a better experience of the different tastes. Wonderful owners very attentive and super friendly- we will make the 75 minute drive again within the month to try even more dishes. Hopefully to bring more of the family as I explained to one of the owners my sister is vegetarian and she said no problem as she is vegetarian also!
5 /5
=

6.Monterrey Mexican Grill

Address: 1303 NY-414, Waterloo, NY 13165

(225) user ratings total:

Rachel Huntzinger Delicious. We will be back. Carne asada was amazing and large portions. Very reasonable prices. Two minute walk from the truck stop with their own truck parking.
5 /5
=

7.Woodys Bar and Grille

Address: 2468 NY-414, Waterloo, NY 13165

(196) user ratings total:

Crista Furgeson Omg the food tho...all of what we had was amazing...French onion soup, clams casino, fried fish...the sauce on Alfredo seemed like a jar sauce. Not thick enough...bread w marinara was so yum...
5 /5
=

8.The Green Apple

Address: 19 W Main St, Waterloo, NY 13165

(189) user ratings total:

Patricia Chong I got the french toast with eggs and bacon. It was great and the egg is creamy, I just wish the cheese was more melted to blend it more. My daughter had the pancake with whipped cream. She was very happy for the way its shaped. They have a large selection of breakfast food on the menu and I noticed that they really have large servings. Very affordable price as well!
5 /5
=

9.Portico at del Lago Resort and Casino

Address: 1133 NY-414, Waterloo, NY 13165

(166) user ratings total:

Selma Adydan I was invited to A wine tasting six course dinner at Porto prepared by Marcus the chef at Portocol when I got there I was a little disappointed because I am allergic to seafood, but somehow Marcus, even though he had about 60 people to take care of plus the rest of the restaurant he turned it all around And made it the most enjoyable dinner that I’ve had at Porto in forever I want to personally thank Del Lago Casino for inviting my husband and myself to this wonderful event and thank you, Marcus for making it so special. Everything was delicious you went above and beyond to make sure I enjoyed my dinner. I didn’t give it a second thought about my allergies to seafood You just made up for it in all ways. You then came out and greeted your guest and was so pleasant with your family and the rest of the staff at Portico can’t wait until our next visit thank you again Selma and DAVE
5 /5
=

10.McDonalds

Address: 2500 Mound Road, Waterloo, NY 13165

images McDonalds

(1459) user ratings total:

Gustavo Herrera This is the best McDonalds by far. All the people I interacted with was very attentive. Specially one fine lady that, sadly, had finished her shift by the time I tried to learn her name and commend her.
5 /5
=

11.Sociale Café at del Lago Resort & Casino

Address: 1133 NY-414, Waterloo, NY 13165

(139) user ratings total:

S Jobin Sat at the bar in the relaxed but classy atmosphere. The staff was pleasant and attentive. The waitress didn’t like the look of my shrimp and sent them back before even showing them to me, which was super considerate! Fried shrimp were perfectly crispy tempura, not heavy breading. The pork pot stickers were very flavorful.
5 /5
=

12.Lizard’s Tailgator Lounge

Address: 40 Church St, Waterloo, NY 13165

(139) user ratings total:

Paige Pellegrini Amazing place!!! First time at a bar for my 21st birthday! Great people and environment. There’s a live band and an electric jukebox to keep the vibes going all night. No pool table but there is darts. Lots of great drinks all night, would definitely recommend!!
5 /5
=

13.Ciccinos Pizzeria & Restaurant

Address: 22 E Main St, Waterloo, NY 13165

images Ciccinos Pizzeria & Restaurant

(1312) user ratings total:

Breanna Holland The staff were very kind and my boyfriend and I had a very good time. The chicken Parm was amazing and huge, and the cannoli was absolutely perfect. The tiramisu was also very delicious. I will be back soon!
5 /5
=

14.Steak and Potato

Address: Finger lake Premium Outlets (Food Court, 655 NY-318 #31D, Waterloo, NY 13165

(120) user ratings total:

Amir Hanafi Excellent spot for a mall fast-food joint. Has a good variety of dishes, serves steak, chicken and fish and a lot of sides including salads, baked potatoes, fries and mozzarella sticks. They even have HALAL chicken sandwich and a veggie burger too! Pretty good menu and the prices are within acceptable range. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.
5 /5
=

15.Bourbon & Brew

Address: 1133 NY-414, Waterloo, NY 13165

(12) user ratings total:

Tom Gross This is a great place to catch the game. Hailee and Ashley were absolutely rockin’ the bar, even on a busy day — their service was top-notch! I started with the cup of chili and a side salad, and both were excellent. Honestly, the salad exceeded my expectations, and the chili had that comforting, homemade flavor. I’d definitely order them again. My brother went with the Reuben and fries, and he loved every bite. Great food, great service, and a fun atmosphere — well be back!
5 /5
=