Recommended 4 Dinner Spots Near Monticello, New York

Luke Matias A classic American diner spot only a 10-minute Uber from Resort World Catskills I was pleasantly surprised by this diner. The interior beauty harkens back to the classic American dining experience with a hint of extra class found in the wooden liveries and warm lighting. My coworkers and I came in for a late lunch and had a seamless experience that came with well informed recommendations on the menu from the polite waiter whose name unfortunately escapes me. The food was excellent, a healthy mix of classic Breakfast diner options with other home stay meals that were very fair portions for the price.

Adam Lorber Being from Long Island, there is no shortage of diners. We came to the Catskills for a 3 day getaway. Tillys diner was one of the best highlights of our trip. We were staying at Resorts World but wanted to explore the area. This diner makes everything from scratch and has a great classic old diner feel. The servers were very friendly, the prices were great and quantity/quality of food is amazing. We ended up coming to Tillys 3 times over 3 days rather than eating at Resorts World. We highly recommend this diner.

Dan Biechele We were staying at the Best Western next to this restaurant. Kat from the BW suggested the Colosseum. The food and the staff were both very good! I chose the peach salmon special, it was wonderful and tasty. My wife selected linguine marinara with shrimp, thoroughly enjoyed it. We went back the next day for dinner as well. I ordered the grilled chicken salad it was huge. My wife had a side salad and we split a side of meatballs and sauce. Again all was very good. I highly recommend this place.

Crissibeth Cooper Its a casual place. I had a hard time deciding what I wanted to eat because there were so many great options. Im vegetarian so I was excited to see that. My spinach pie was very tasty and they really loaded it with spinach generously. Same for the Greek salad--they gave you plenty of olives, tomatoes, etc. which I noticed and appreciated! Service was warm, prompt, and friendly. I will be back a lot.